Monday, May 25, 2009

Strategy Debate

The best evidence of our president’s affirmation that ‘the record is clear’ regarding Guantanamo having generated more terrorists than it has prevented would be that it is mentioned in jihadist recruitment materials. But that does not prove it is an effective recrutement tool. It might be intended for western consumption, to throw confusion into the enemy ranks, which indeed it has done. The record would be clear if it could be demonstrated that a) such mention actually motivated terrorist recruits and b) that this number exceeded the number of those detained. Does a clear record on these points exist? It seems incredible that a group addicted to kidnapping and slitting throats, not discreetly but on video eagerly broadcast to the world, would get excited, one way or the other, by detention under any circumstances and the sort of rough-stuff practiced which has been inflicted on two or three of them during the past eight years.
In any case, to both donkeys and elephants who condemn Guantanamo I would ask: even if the current crop of detainees can be somehow done away with, what do you propose for future un-uniformed jihadist picked up on battle-fields around the world, even if you are not interested in asking them a few little questions but just keeping them off the streets? What, in other words, should the short-sighted junta of Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld have done in the first place?
Despite all the yammer, however, most donkeys and elephants seem to side with the junta, given the massive rejection of funds requested by the president to close Guantanamo, to say nothing of donkey declarations to the effect that “terrorists” (NB, not “agents of man-made disaster” or some other euphemism) are not welcome on US soil, even in the restricted area of a US prison.
The obvious solution is to shoot un-uniformed combatants on the field of battle, per the rules of war. In this we would perhaps deprive ourselves of useful information which might be throttled out of such rascals, but it would spare our sensitive souls the sort of vindictive squawk in which Madam Speaker seems to have over-indulged, and which our new president promised would end on his watch. Even Madam Speaker may now be longing for this more civil era, in which we politely ignore past excess.

Fungibility

Their are problems with Anne Korin’s argument (see Strategic Oil).
A) Expanded US oil production would put downward pressure on the international price which, according to Korin’s assertions, would tend to oblige OPEC to make adjustments. Whether or not OPEC actually did make such adjustments, increased US production would tend to reduce thier income flow; either the price would go down or they would be obliged to reduce their own production to maintain the price.
B) America could create a protected national market by eliminating the gasoline tax on fuel produced from US crude, as well as other fiscal inducements, and perhaps mandating a gasoline price higher than what the market would otherwise call for (which might still be less than what it is today), in order to channel all US production into the domestic market, in effect destroying the fungibility problem. Were this not possible though economic inducements internal production could simply be mandated for internal use. If the USA is truly the biggest energy market in the world, this could hardly be an economic hardship to the producers involved. As for international repercussions, apart from finger-pointing, the effect could not be very important, given the universal nature of the market. I am not the one to make the calculations, but surely there would be a way to make this economically interesting to the producers, and given that a great part of gasoline prices are tax, to the customers as well.
C) Surely the tanker loads of crude oil which criss-cross the oceans protected by the US navy are traceable! It seems amazing that petroleum’s fungibiliy could not be interfered with on the basis of this information.

Sunday, April 26, 2009

Red and Blue

The Orwellian switch by which the American Sodomy Party is ‘republican’ blue, and it’s opponent ‘revolutionary’ red, works violence upon a language older and more universal than music, the elements of which, given the color of sky, water and blood, can never be chosen.
The media mandarins who worked this sly trick have savored their success, but with official designation of returning veterans as a vector of terrorism this stagecraft may be collapsing on these heads of the string-pullers.
The culture wars have had this result: the Sodomy Party owns government, education, traditional media, and a claim of control over public discourse. Their opponents have the army and the ideological adhesion of a majority of American citizens. Having color-designated the latter a revolutionary force, given current developments, the former may prove ironically justified.
We know what a ‘blue’ American will look like: the toothless, threadbare models are in Europe, with a prospect of dhimmi status. What would a ‘red’ America look like? One may hope for a restoration of the spirit of the Constitution, but at first it would look like a break-up of the union and military dictatorship. Such situations have been seen in American history, but not in the context of a globalized and nuclearized world.

Monday, April 13, 2009

Shaggy

Once upon a time there was an evil emperor. But a magic spell put an end to him, and the peasants rejoiced. An evil queen of the north, inspired by a misshapen dwarf who was her court jester, vied for the crown, but the magicians and wise men of the empire appointed a beautiful young prince, beloved of the peasants and all peoples worldwide. A new era of justice and peace was inaugurated. 
The new emperor was married to a magical fairy of great beauty. Her close-set eyes, out-thrust lower lip, stiff hair and fine gowns enchanted everyone. The imperial couple boasted two children, and far and wide it was known that the emperor had made them a wonderful promise: if he were crowned emperor he would give them a dog! But after the coronation months went by, and no dog came.
The affaires of the empire were many and urgent. The imperial gold was depleted. The peasants were suffering. Wars raged. One day a great lord brought a dog to the emperor, who gave it to his children. The children gave the dog a famous name, and the entire world greatly rejoiced.

Sunday, April 12, 2009

Relativism for Easter

There is no truth, only different views. One is that all religions are equally valid. Another is that they are equally invalid. The view of Islam is that Jesus was not the son of God. The view of Christianity is that Islam is a form of Arianism; the heresy, in this case, that Jesus was not the son of God.
Those serious about their relativism take all these views with equal seriousness--since, in particular, the pretension that science has proven that religion is primitive nonsense is itself only an ancent prejudice, a version Eliatic Monism, the hypothesis that the cosmos is made of grains of matter and that change is an illusion. This view, known today as Scientism, offers no explanation about the source of the cosmos (or, to the contrary, the nature of infinity) or the nature of awareness (which might as well be illusory). This, of course, does not prove it is wrong; and anyway it is not a crime to be mistaken, or should not be. 

Friday, April 10, 2009

Our Chrildren's Debt

I have heard this cry my whole life, and Victor Davis Hanson echoed it today: our children and grandchildren for generations, through all sorts of higher taxes, will have to service the mountain of debt and interest for the larger entitlements we’ll soon receive. That, or the system will break down. Loans will go unpaid on a massive scale destroying the trust and confidence which is the basis of economic prosperity, igniting a period of poverty unprecedented in modern times. If the American economy sloughs into 3d world mode Curtis Lemay's bombs will not be needed to shift China and India back into the stone age from which they so recently emerged. Europe, which has demonstrated little economic independence, will strangle.
After the cataclysm Americans would surely carry themselves as quickly as possible to internal recovery. The test might even be a tonic to the national spirit. After such a massive thievery the return to familiar levels of world-prosperity will not be a matter of trimesters but of generations; never before has America betrayed the world. 

Thursday, April 9, 2009

"France"

For the American conservative movement 'France' has become a dirty word. Pundits who can quote the Founding fathers on the place of Christianity in the American founding or America's role in the maintenance of freedom in Europe through the 20th century, fail to mention that it was only thanks to France that America exists.
It was Admiral de Grasse who planned the battle of Yorktown, defeated the English fleet, and put almost as many French troops into the fight as there were American. The treasure engaged was that of the French nation. That Louis XVI had larger purposes, if he did, changes nothing: no French help, no United States of America.
My wife was twenty four years old in 1944 when America invaded France. Her father fought at Verdun, a battle in a war whose victory was made possible by an American army. Ariving in France General Pershing famously declared: “Lafayette, nous voilĂ ”. My wife, however, is sympathetic to the new American attitude. She is disgusted at French anti-Americanism, and several other aspects of her country. Her attitude is shared by many but they lack a voice.
France, with less freedom than America, has not seen the emergence of anything comparable to the “conservative movement”. But, even with one side mute, the 'culture war' rages also in Europe.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Wilson Redux

At last: the progressive vision is in power. Like cats watching a king we are seeing it articulated nationally and internationally.
We are also witness to its non-implementation. However placed the heart, however suave the toung, however good the look, the stars will not be charmed from their paths. It is like explaining the basis of civilization to an armed thief who has you at his mercy. So, to mention only the most contemptible aspect, no entity of substance will oppose even a rhetorical flourish to the comic opera playing at Geneva.
Will this renewed experiment, looming above those with eyes to see like a 20th century storm cloud, be the final one? Will the vast failure, if not conflagration, which stalks us, cleanse at last the utopian contagion from our minds? Even the school of hard knocks can teach nothing to the mindless, as has also been seen again and again.

Tuesday, April 7, 2009

Strategic Oil

The West is funding jehadi mischief. How can the cycle be broken?
Anne Korin, in a highly coherent presentation, argues that oil is a “strategic” resource because transportation is hostage to it, whereas the US uses virtually no oil to generate electricity. OPEC, she demonstrates, is a cartel which profits no matter who produces or sells the stuff.
With economic and technological arguments Korin advocates a law mandating flex-motors coupled with batteries, after which the market does the rest. 

Monday, April 6, 2009

Torture

Torture, we are told, is ineffective. The idea is that the accused will confess under torture but the innocent, strong in the truth, will have the nerve to resist. This might be true, or publicly defensible, in societies of honor but not in societies of physical gratification. But the idea breaks down because some people are beyond innocence and guilt; they just have pleanty of nerve, and this is not written on thier faces.
When it is not a matter of personal confessions the situation is different. Let us imagine we wish to squeeze information about our enemy from tight-lipped captives. Like the accused of the previous case some have nerve and some not. But here we do not care about confession. We want information which any of the captives might have equally. If some have nerves, others might not. Whatever information is culled can then be checked, and is only one aspect of an informational picture being drawn up from several sources.